A Delicious Abomination: The Garbage Plate Explained

When it comes to unique dishes, few are as divisive yet beloved as the Garbage Plate (also known as the Trash Plate or simply plate).

Origins and Naming

The Garbage Plate, a staple in the Rochester, NY food scene, has quite an interesting history. Served at various diners, this dish goes by different names to avoid legal disputes with the original Nick Tahou's on Main Street. Diners in Rochester and beyond have taken it upon themselves to assign numerous monikers, but the essence of the dish remains the same: an extravagant mix of meats, traditional sides, and a mouth-watering spicy sauce.

Popular Variations

The Garbage Plate is a veritable buffet of flavors and textures. The core components of the dish are:

Cheeseburger or hamburger: A hearty beef patty topped with cheese, a staple in this dish. Italian Sausage: Often included for an extra layer of flavor and richness. White or Red Hots: Served as a side, adding a spicy kick. Home Fries or French Fries: Crispy and fluffy, adding a satisfying crunch to the plate. Baked Beans and Macaroni Salad: Traditional accompaniments that bring out different nuances of the dish.

The Star Sauce is the true terrorist of the plate, and it's what many would describe as a "spicy meat sauce." This sauce is what elevates the Garbage Plate to its legendary status. It's the element that fans can't get enough of, and it's what often separates those who love it from those who just eat it out of curiosity.

Apps and Recommendations

While the term "Garbage Plate" might sound unappetizing, it's a dish that stands on its own merits. For those looking to try it but maybe not all at once, there are a few recommendations:

Side Dishes: Order sides like baked beans or macaroni salad to savor these traditional accompaniments without overwhelming your palate. Customizable Orders: Many diners offer customizable orders, allowing you to reduce portion sizes or exclude meats for a healthier option. Start Small: Approach the Garbage Plate with smaller portions or try portions of each component separately.

While it might not be the healthiest option, the Garbage Plate is an occasional treat that encapsulates the spirit of indulgence and the unique flavors of Rochester, NY. Whether you're a meat lover or just curious, this iconic dish is worth experiencing at least once!

Conclusion

The Garbage Plate, whether you call it a Garbage Plate, Trash Plate, or just a plate, is a quintessential part of Rochester's culinary landscape. Despite its name, it's a dish that offers a flavor explosion of textures and tastes. For locals and visitors alike, it's a chance to embrace the unconventional and experience a piece of local culture. So, take a chance and delve into the world of the Garbage Plate – you might just find it worth the fuss!