Bike Bag or Pannier: Which is Better for Bike Packing?
Bike packing has become increasingly popular in recent years, allowing cyclists to explore remote and challenging terrains with more comfort and flexibility. When it comes to choosing between a bike bag and panniers, the decision can often depend on the specific needs and preferences of the rider. In this article, we will explore the merits of both options, helping you make an informed choice for your next bike packing adventure.
My Preferred Setup: Rear Rack and Small Panniers
For my own bike packing setup, I prefer a rear rack with small Arkel Dry-Lite 14-liter per bag soft panniers. The rack provides a stable platform for an additional 15-20-liter soft bag, such as a dry bag, which together offer 40-50 liters of packing space. The rack weighs under 2 pounds but offers excellent flexibility in organizing gear, clothing, and other items. The main reason for not using a traditional rack and panniers is the need for hike-a-bike sections. Traditional larger panniers can interfere with pushing the bike up narrow and steep trails, causing them to contact the rider's legs. Small, modern soft panniers eliminate this issue.
In contrast, I do use bike bags in the front triangle and on the front handlebars. This setup allows for convenient access and swift packing, especially when the ride requires flexibility and rapid gear adjustments.
Bike-Packing Defined: Lightweight vs. Sturdy
Bike-packing, generally, refers to ultralightweight bicycle touring, which often involves using bike bags over panniers. This approach sacrifices storage space for weight savings, making it ideal for riders seeking to carry minimal gear. In such scenarios, bike bags can weigh as little as 5-10 pounds, providing excellent portability and ease of transport, especially for long distances.
On the other hand, panniers are considered the standard for bicycle touring arrangements. While they are typically heavier than bike bags, panniers ensure that you carry everything you need, even in remote areas. For riders who value comprehensive storage solutions and are willing to carry additional weight, panniers are an excellent choice.
The Benefits of Panniers
Panniers offer several advantages over bike bags:
1. Low Center of Gravity
Panniers sit low on the bike, keeping the center of gravity lower. This makes your bike more stable and easier to handle, even when carrying a significant amount of weight. Most bike bags mount on the frame in front of the handlebars or behind the seat, causing the bike's handling to change dramatically if you pack a lot of weight in these areas.
2. Comfort
Panniers ride over the wheels and hubs, meaning that the majority of the weight is distributed over the tires. This design allows the tires to absorb the majority of road noise and bumps, resulting in a more comfortable ride, especially during long tours.
I have a variety of bags, including frame bags, large saddle bags, handlebar bags, and panniers. For multi-day trips, I start by mounting a frame bag in the center of my frame, followed by panniers, a large saddle bag, and a handlebar bag if needed. If all of my gear fits in the frame bag and panniers, I don't bring the saddle or handlebar bag.
3. Trail Considerations
The only exception to this order would be on tight trails, where panniers could be a hindrance due to added width. In such situations, I opt for a seat bag and handlebar bag to keep the bike's profile more narrow, ensuring easier navigation.
Conclusion
Whether you choose bike bags or panniers depends on your specific needs, the terrain, and your preference for weight and storage. Both options have their unique advantages, and the choice ultimately comes down to your personal requirements and intended use. Whether you prioritize ultralight gear or comprehensive storage, there is a setup that will meet your bike packing needs.