Converting a Gas Fireplace to Wood Burning: Is It Feasible?
Understanding the Conversion Process
When it comes to converting a gas fireplace to a wood burning option, the process is not straightforward and depends on the original setup of the fireplace. A critical factor is whether the fireplace was originally designed for wood burning and subsequently converted to gas. If that's the case, it might be more feasible, but it's still highly unlikely. Additionally, the structure's integrity and the risk of fire hazards need to be scrutinized.
Why is this so complicated? The heart of the difference lies in the materials and design. Gas fireplaces are constructed using light-weight steel, which can't withstand the intense heat and combustion requirements of wood. In contrast, wood-burning fireplaces are made with firebrick due to their durability and heat resistance. To convert, you would essentially need to tear out the gas unit and reinstall a wood-burning one. However, this option is often not legally permissible in many areas, due to stringent environmental regulations imposed to protect air quality.
Legal and Environmental Considerations
The process isn't just about feasibility. It also involves legal repercussions and environmental implications. In many parts of California, it is explicitly forbidden to install new wood-burning stoves or fireplaces. This is a direct response to concerns about air pollution. If you still wish to proceed for personal satisfaction, you will be using a more environmentally damaging fuel than natural gas. This approach will negate any potential environmental benefits one might have hoped to achieve by switching from gas to wood.
Alternative Solutions
While the thought of converting a gas fireplace into a wood-burning one might be enticing due to the allure of the crackling fire, there are simpler and more practical solutions. One such solution involves using an andiron over the gas jets. An andiron is a metal stand or device used to hold burning firewood. The gas jets can be turned off once the wood in the andiron catches, allowing you to enjoy a natural fire without converting the entire unit. This is a much safer and legally compliant alternative that can also offer an aesthetically pleasing wood-burning experience.
Why Not Put a Wood Fire in a Gas Fireplace?
The risks associated with putting a wood fire in a gas fireplace are significant. The metal casing of a gas fireplace lacks the robustness of firebrick, meaning it can't handle the intense heat generated by a wood fire. Without a proper chimney to draw smoke and heat upward, there is a substantial fire hazard. Furthermore, a gas fireplace isn't designed to support the weight and force of a wood fire, which could compromise its structural integrity and lead to severe damage or even a fire outbreak. It's crucial to prioritize safety above all else when considering any fireplace modification.
To further emphasize the importance of safety, a typical gas fireplace's inner structure is not equipped to handle the higher temperatures and intense combustion of wood. This can result in serious hazards such as cracks, intense heat dispersion, and an increased risk of fires. While the urge to switch to wood burning might be strong, safety should always take precedence in such situations.
While the idea of converting a gas fireplace to a wood-burning one might seem appealing, the complexity, legal restrictions, and safety concerns make it a challenging endeavor. The alternative solutions available, such as using an andiron over the gas jets, offer a safer, more practical, and legally compliant way to enjoy wood-burning heat. It's important to weigh these factors carefully to ensure both enjoyment and safety in your home.