Effectiveness of Border Wall in Deterrence of Illegal Immigration: An Analysis

Recently, the topic of building a border wall between the United States and Mexico has reemerged in discussions about immigration policy. The effectiveness of such a border wall in deterring illegal immigration has been a subject of debate. This article examines the legality, feasibility, and impact of border walls on illegal immigration.

The 2018-2020 Data: A Proven Deterrent

It is important to note that the construction of a border wall has proven to be effective in reducing the number of illegal immigrants entering the United States. Data from 2018, 2019, and 2020 has shown a significant decrease in the number of illegal aliens entering the country. This proves that a physical barrier can indeed make a substantial impact on illegal immigration.

Reality Check: Most Illegal Entrants Enter by Air

Contrary to popular belief, the majority of illegal immigrants enter the United States by air. According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, approximately two-thirds of all illegal immigrants come into the country via commercial flights. This means that building a border wall to deter illegal entry would have limited effectiveness since it does not address air travel.

Legality and Feasibility of Building a Wall

Building a wall around Mexico would require the permission of the Mexican government, which raises legal and diplomatic concerns. Pursuant to international law, such an action would be considered an invasion. Therefore, it is not a feasible option. However, the United States has the authority to build a wall on its own territory along the border with Mexico.

Strategic Solutions

While a border wall can serve as a deterrent, it is important to combine it with other strategic solutions for effective immigration control. The Biden administration addressed a significant number of illegal immigrants who were invited and welcomed into the country. To combat this, it is crucial to:

Triple the size of CBP (U.S. Customs and Border Protection). Additional resources, including personnel, would enhance the ability to patrol and secure the border. Build CBP substations along the border. These substations would provide better surveillance and response capabilities. Deploy border patrol guards with towers. Regular patrols and surveillance would help identify and apprehend illegal crossers.

Conclusion

The construction of a border wall can contribute to the deterrence of illegal immigration, but it is not a comprehensive solution on its own. To effectively address the issue, the U.S. government must implement a multi-pronged strategy that includes increased border security, enhanced border patrol activities, and comprehensive immigration policies.