Why George C. Scott Chose to Portray Patton as a Human Being
The iconic George S. Patton, often remembered as a military icon with an almost mythic persona, has captured the attention of filmmakers and historians for decades. Despite his inspiring achievements, his character is depicted in various films, each offering a different perspective. One such portrayal stands out in “Patton”, where George C. Scott delivered a performance that blurred the lines between mascot and man. Was Scott attempting to present Patton as a human being rather than an icon? This analysis delves into why such a portrayal was significant and what it tells us about the man behind the legend.
Icon or Human Being? The Debate Continues
Many viewers of the film “Patton” have argued that Scott's portrayal of the famous general came across as harsh and unforgiving, emphasizing the "miserable SOB" aspect of Patton's character. These critiques are often rooted in a desire for a more flattering depiction of the general. However, as this article will explore, George C. Scott may not have intended to portray Patton as an unflattering caricature but rather as a complex individual with both strengths and shortcomings.
Scott's Realistic Representation of Patton
It is essential to consider the historical context in which George C. Scott lived. Scott, born in 1927, was well aware of the general circumstances of the time and the true nature of Patton's personality. By the time he took on the role of Patton for “Patton”, Scott had already developed a reputation as a versatile and talented actor. His portrayal of Patton was aimed at capturing the general as he perceived him through his own experiences and observations.
Scott's depiction of Patton was a straightforward illustration of the general's humanity, emphasizing his imperfections and struggles. This approach allowed Scott to humanize the icon, presenting Patton as a man of action rather than a larger-than-life figure. Such a portrayal aimed to give audiences a more balanced and realistic view of the military leader, rather than simply glorifying him or vilifying him.
Challenging Iconic Status
One of the critical points of Scott's portrayal was his emphasis on the intricate mix of charisma and cruelty that characterized Patton's personality. While Patton was undoubtedly a renowned military figure, his mannerisms and conduct, especially under pressure, were often abrasive and difficult to work with. Scott's performance highlighted these aspects, making the general relatable and more than just a symbol of American valor.
By portraying Patton as a human being, the film aimed to provide a more nuanced understanding of the man behind the iconic figure. This nuanced approach aligns with the film's title, "“Band of Brothers”," which suggested a deep human connection and shared experience. Similarly, the famous line from the film, "“Guts: Our Blood”," emphasized the bravery and sacrifice of both the general and his men.
Conclusion
In conclusion, George C. Scott's portrayal of George S. Patton in the film “Patton” was not a mistake or a deliberate attempt to diminish Patton's legacy. Instead, it was a conscious effort to present the general as a multifaceted individual, a man full of strength and flaws. This realistic representation challenges the iconic status often associated with the general and provides viewers with a more complex and human understanding of one of the most influential military figures of the 20th century.