Joseph Smith: Prophet or Fraud?

The question of who Joseph Smith was is a complex and often contentious one. There are starkly opposing views on this early Mormon leader, and this article aims to explore the various perspectives while also presenting insights based on personal experience and scholarly research.

The Mythical Joseph Smith

There are those who see Joseph Smith as a divine figure, akin to a modern-day prophet. His admirers often view him as the ultimate expression of God's will on Earth. Smith is referred to as the last prophet of God, the new Chosen One, and blessed by God in a way that no other has ever been. Critics, however, would argue that such views are nothing more than wishful thinking or blind faith.

For instance, the untimely deaths of his first three children at a young age pose serious ethical questions. Yet, in the eyes of believers, these tragedies are seen as divinely ordained, and they stand before Elohim, Christ, and Joseph Smith in the afterlife. This perspective is often dismissed by those who prioritize truth and objectivity over faith.

The Sordid Reality of Joseph Smith

Another camp views Joseph Smith as a complex individual, more deeply flawed than many believe. The stories of his engaging in secular fraud, particularly the practice of treasure digging and subsequently shifting to religious grifting, provide a startlingly different picture. Smith's rise to power and wealth led him to adopt a more lax moral stance, allowing him to endorse adultery as long as it received God's approval.

By exploring Smith's character in light of historical evidence and testimonies, one can draw comparisons to other controversial religious figures such as L. Ron Hubbard, David Koresh, and Rulon Warren Jeffs. The latter are known for their leadership roles in cults, which further muddles the narrative around Smith's ethical standing.

Restoring the Gospel

Despite the controversies, many members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) see Joseph Smith as a remarkable figure whose efforts have brought about significant religious and social transformations. The core beliefs and practices restored through his leadership have greatly influenced millions of people worldwide.

In just 23 years, Smith achieved numerous milestones that have contributed to the development of Mormonism into a global religion. He:

Restored the true character of God the Father and Jesus Christ, emphasizing their distinct identities and physical forms. Translated an ancient text, The Book of Mormon, into English and published it as another testament of Jesus Christ. Founded a worldwide church with millions of members in nearly every country. Reintroduced temple worship and established the first temple of God in Kirtland, Ohio. Published other revealed scripture in the Doctrine and Covenants and Pearl of Great Price. Founded a city in Nauvoo, Illinois, which rivalled Chicago in commerce and growth. Restored true priesthood authority and the saving ordinances of the gospel. Returned true doctrine that had been corrupted by centuries of uninspired men.

These accomplishments speak to the profound impact Smith had on the religious landscape, and many believe he was a true prophet inspired by God.

Conclusion

How one views Joseph Smith ultimately depends on one's perspective. For believers, his character and accomplishments are a testament to his divine calling. For critics, his life and actions highlight the complexities and flaws inherent in any individual, even those who claim divine influence.