Should You Reglaze or Replace Your Bathhtub?

Deciding whether to reglaze or replace your bathtub can be a daunting task, but with the right information, you can make an informed decision that maximizes both your financial budget and the overall appearance of your bathroom. This article will explore the benefits and drawbacks of each option, helping you to choose the best solution for your needs.

Cost Comparison: Refinishing vs. Replacement

When considering whether to reglaze or replace your bathtub, one of the primary factors is cost. Refinishing a tub can often be a more affordable option, potentially saving you a significant amount of money compared to a new tub. On average, refinishing a tub can cost less than a third of the cost of buying and installing a new one. This makes it a more financially prudent option, especially if you're looking to update your bathroom without spending a large sum of money.

Case Study: Our Experience with Reglazing

We recently reglazed our bathtub and were thoroughly satisfied with the results. The cost was approximately 20% of what it would have been to buy a new tub. This experience not only confirmed our belief that reglazing is cost-effective but also that it can provide an excellent aesthetic improvement. The refinished surface looked and felt like new, with no signs of wear and tear.

Best Company for Refinishing: JLF Tub and Tile Reglazing

For those considering bathtub refinishing, JLF Tub and Tile Reglazing is highly recommended. This company provides excellent service and has a proven track record of success. They offer a range of services, including epoxied paint refinishing, which can transform your bathtub into a beautiful, fresh space. Whether you're looking for a simple color change or a complete transformation, JLF Tub and Tile Reglazing can handle the job.

Epoxy Paint Refinishing for Rentals

If you own a rental property, epoxy paint refinishing can be a quick and effective solution. For a rental with a blue tub, this type of refinishing can make a significant difference. However, it's important to note that from a resale standpoint, it may not significantly increase the property's value. In fact, unique features like clawfoot tubs may be more valuable if they remain in place. Clawfoot tubs are favored by romantics and are quite heavy, weighing about 300-400 lbs, which can make moving them and adjusting the plumbing quite challenging.

Considerations for DIY Refinishing

For those considering doing the bathtub refinishing themselves, it's essential to take the necessary steps to ensure a successful outcome. First, thoroughly clean the bathtub with TSP (Trisodium Phosphate) to remove any dirt and grime. An anti-slip finish can be applied to add safety, especially if you plan to shower in the tub. It's also important to consider getting a rubber mat, as slips and falls in the bathtub can expose you to potential lawsuits.

Challenges of Shower Installations

While showers have become fashionable, replacing your bathtub with one could limit your client base. Older individuals, women who stand for long periods, and mothers with young children often prefer a tub. Additionally, the risks of water damage with a shower are significantly higher. In a basement unit, the risk of water spilling over and causing flooding is much greater, even with a 1.5-inch border. Should a city-wide sewer overflow occur, a shower's drainage system may not be sufficient to contain the water, potentially leading to extensive property damage.

Moreover, the risk of such damage may not be covered by your insurance company anymore, and dealing with lawsuits can be a complex matter. As a real estate investor or owner, you don't need such complications and potential issues.

Overall, whether you choose to reglaze or replace your bathtub, carefully consider the cost, aesthetic appeal, and long-term practicality. Both options have their merits, and the right choice will depend on your specific needs and circumstances.