The Challenges of Switching from Propane to Natural Gas for Home Appliances
Introduction
When considering alternative energy sources for home appliances such as a tankless water heater, dryer, and range, natural gas is often a top contender. However, the decision to switch from propane to natural gas involves several factors and potential drawbacks. This article explores the challenges of making this switch, including the practical considerations and economic implications.
Real Drawbacks: Lack of Infrastructure
Lack of Gas Line: The primary challenge is the absence of a gas line in your home. If you do not have a pre-existing gas supply, connecting to the local natural gas network may be impossible or impractical.
Propane Distribution Network: In some neighborhoods with community LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) distribution networks, it may be possible to obtain a connection. However, this is subject to the discretion of the natural gas distributor and the financial feasibility for the homeowner.
According to a previous comparison, natural gas costs significantly less than propane on a heating value basis. This makes natural gas an attractive option for homes without existing gas lines.
Cost Considerations
Installation Costs: When comparing the expenses of installing a natural gas connection versus purchasing a propane storage tank, the natural gas route becomes economically favorable, especially if an existing gas line is present. Propane storage tanks can be expensive and require ongoing maintenance.
Lease vs. Purchase: Some propane companies offer leases with meters to charge based on usage, which can be more expensive than directly switching to natural gas.
Conversion Considerations
Compatibility: Many gas appliances can be converted between natural gas and propane by simply changing the gas orifices. This conversion process is typically best and safer handled by certified gas installers to ensure safety and efficiency.
Bill vs. Purchase: Natural gas is often billed as used, while propane is usually purchased in advance. The risk of funds being tied up in a tankful of propane that is still being used can make it less convenient. However, some propane companies offer lease arrangements, which can be less costly in the long run but add upfront costs and financial risks.
The decision to switch from propane to natural gas involves careful consideration of the specific challenges and potential drawbacks. While natural gas offers cost savings and convenience in many cases, the practical and economic details must be carefully evaluated to ensure the best outcome for your household.