The Reasoning Behind Full Service Gas Stations in New Jersey

New Jersey is one of the few states that still insists on full service gas stations, a stark contrast to many parts of the United States where self-service is the norm. This preference is rooted in a complex interplay of public opinion, legal considerations, and economic motivations. Let's delve into the reasoning behind this unique situation.

The Public’s Preference and Strong Public Opinion

Public opinion plays a significant role in the persistence of full service gas stations in New Jersey. The idea of manual service stands as a nostalgic and enjoyable ritual for many residents. Nobody wants to manually pump gas when they can have someone do it for them at no additional cost.

Historical Context

Several other states have embraced self-service gas stations, touting potential savings of up to $0.25 per gallon. However, these states have often experienced backlash from the public. New Jersey residents, like those in other states, have demonstrated a strong resistance to change, maintaining their preference for full service stations. This resistance is underpinned by the belief that the attendant's role goes beyond just filling the tank and extends to ensuring safety and convenience.

The Economic Arguments

The primary economic argument against self-service stations is the potential increase in insurance premiums. Without the oversight of trained service attendants, unskilled customers handling the pumps present a higher risk. As a result, gas stations may have to pay higher insurance premiums, negating any potential savings to the consumer.

Profit Margins and Savings

Some gas stations in states that transitioned to self-service did manage to pass on the savings to their customers. However, in New Jersey, the gas stations did not necessarily return the full savings to customers. In fact, the gas companies raised the price of full-service gas by $0.25 to cover the cost of additional security and insurance.

Local Reality

While full service stations have managed to withstand economic pressures, the reality on the ground in New Jersey can sometimes be tempered by occasional incidents. For example, one instance vividly illustrates why the service is still valuable. At a gas station, a young person impatiently started filling his truck while smoking a lit cigarette, almost causing a dangerous situation. Fortunately, a quick-thinking attendant intervened and prevented a disaster.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Despite the potential for savings through self-service, New Jersey's full-service stations continue to thrive. The combination of strong public opinion and economic reasons ensures that these stations remain a staple in the state. However, as regulations and technology evolve, the future of full service gas stations in New Jersey remains an interesting area of observation.