The Smiths: Are They Overrated or Influential?

The debate over whether The Smiths are overrated or not is a contentious one. Some music critics and fans hail them as one of the most influential bands of the 1980s, while others, including this author, see them as a boring and overly embarrassing group.

Perception of The Smiths

On one hand, many consider The Smiths to be one of the most influential bands of the 1980s. Their music, with themes of alienation, love, and social commentary, has kept their work relevant to this day. This sentiment is echoed by The Critical Consensus, which states: 'They had all the right influences... But they didn’t sound at least stylistically like their influences. They sounded original.'

The Controversy

However, personal taste plays a significant role in evaluating bands. For instance, this author strongly opposes The Smiths, stating, 'Morrissey is such a terrible singer and ridiculous lyricist.' In light of this, it's fair to ask a subjective question: Are The Smiths overrated?

The Critical Consensus

Despite the controversy, the critical consensus is that The Smiths were one of the best bands of their era. Here are just a few reasons why:

Right Influences: They were heavily influenced by classic rock and punk bands such as The Stooges, The Velvet Underground, The Stones, Motown, Sex Pistols, New York Dolls, Ramones, Cilla Black, Dusty Springfield, and Sandie Shaw. Authentic and Original: As a guitar band, they were more credible than synth-heavy New Wave acts. Post-punk had evolved into synth-heavy New Wave, but The Smiths brought a fresh sound to the scene. Literary Genius: Morrissey's lyrics were sophisticated, and Johnny Marr's music was catchy and sophisticated, making their songs rewarding to listen to repeatedly. Universal Appeal: Despite being described by Morrissey as a 'crybaby,' his themes resonated with alienated youth and contributed to the band's lasting legacy. Influential: The Smiths' impact extends across genres, influencing artists from EDM to alternative rock, including Paul Van Dyk, Coldplay, Oasis, and The National. They became a touchstone for many alternative and modern rock bands.

Conclusion

While personal taste inevitably colors opinions, it's clear that The Smiths have left a profound mark on music. If you disagree, consider giving some of their standout songs a listen to see if they can change your mind. Some recommendations include 'Well I Wonder,' 'Please Please Please Let Me Get What I Want,' 'This Night Has Opened My Eyes,' and 'Death of a Disco Dancer.'

Ultimately, the verdict on whether The Smiths are overrated or influential is up to individual preference. Whether you find their music rewarding or embarrassing, exploring their work might offer some new perspectives.