When Putin Claims Wagner Does Not Exist, Is the Russian State Also in Question?
In a recent statement, Vladimir Putin, the President of Russia, made a tantalizing claim: that the Private Military Company (PMC) Wagner does not exist. However, this bold assertion can be interpreted in multiple ways, with implications that extend far beyond simply denying the existence of a military entity. This article delves into why Putin might be making this claim, what it means for the Russian state, and the underlying issues surrounding Wagner. We will also explore the impact of Putin's past statements and actions on Russian and global perception.
Unraveling Putin's True Intentions
The assertion that Wagner does not exist is a stark statement that goes beyond mere denials. It suggests a deeper issue with the transparency and legitimacy of the Russian government. Yevgeny Prigozhin, the founder and leader of Wagner, is reported to have met with a colleague behind closed doors at the Russia-Africa conference, indicating that there are private discussions and dealings that are far removed from the public eye.
Wagner: A Dark Force
Wagner, a PMC that operates much like the French Foreign Legion or Blackwater, is wholly funded by the Russian taxpayers through the Ministry of Defense. Despite this, the deals with African dictators are made in backroom deals, with Prigozhin taking a significant cut, effectively stealing from Africans and the Russian taxpayers. This is a deeply troubling practice that raises questions about the integrity and accountability of the Russian state.
The Neo-Nazi Factor
The founders and chief commandants of Wagner, including Mr. Utkin, have ties to neo-Nazism. This is deeply troubling as it suggests a strategic partnership with extremist groups, which is not a small matter even in the shadowy world of PMC operations. Wagner is named after Richard Wagner, a composer famous for his admiration of Adolph Hitler. This raises major ethical questions about the values and intentions behind Wagner's operations.
The Existence of the Russian State?
If Wagner does not exist, then by logical extension, the Russian state as it is currently constituted may also be in question. The Russian state, as Putin describes it, is a figment of collective imagination. This statement, while seemingly paradoxical, can be interpreted as a warning or a challenge to the very structure of the state. It's a statement that could signal that the state might collapse if Putin continues to deny the existence of its key components.
Putin's History of Deception
Putin's history of lying is well-documented, and his most recent statement about Wagner is just one example. For example, the 2022 Michelin Guide awarded a restaurant in Moscow a 'red badge of courage,' while Russian TV commercials celebrating Prigozhin's mutiny as an act of patriotism, despite his involvement in shooting down Russian military helicopters and warplanes en route to Moscow. This narrative presents Prigozhin as a hero, a true patriot, and a strong leader of Russia.
Public Perception and Reality
However, Putin's misleading narratives and his actions do not align with public perception. Russians who have been brainwashed by the state media and some underdeveloped African nations are the only ones who still trust Putin. Few people, except for those deeply embedded in the system, believe his lies. Just as a house of cards falls when one card is removed, the Russian state risks collapse if Putin continues to deny the parts that sustain it.
The Consequences of Putin's Denial
The consequences of Putin's denial of Wagner's existence are significant. Not only does it imply a lack of transparency and accountability, but it also threatens the very fabric of governance in Russia. If the core parts of the state are being ignored, it raises questions about the state's legitimacy, its ability to govern effectively, and its willingness to address the real problems facing the nation.
A Tales of the Unexpected
The claim that Wagner does not exist is not just about denial; it is about hiding the truth, which can backfire in numerous ways. For instance, in 2022, Prigozhin launched a mutiny, which was later spun by the Russian government as a patriotic act. Two years later, the same tower in Moscow that was previously awarded a Michelin Guide badge, the IQ Tower, was hit by a drone. This suggests that the lightning can indeed strike the same place twice, indicating that the denial of the existence of Wagner has real-world implications.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Putin's recent denial of Wagner's existence is not just a political maneuver but a statement that challenges the very foundations of the Russian state. It reveals a lack of transparency, deep-seated corruption, and a play to maintain control through deceit. The real question remains: can a state that hides its dark realities truly govern effectively? The answer is no, and the current crisis within Russia is a testament to this truth.
Support this article by following and donating to the Moscow-based dissident writer:
Support the Dissident Writer