Why Burrowing Should Be Considered a Fundamental Right
Earlier this year, an incident in New York City brought to light a fascinating and somewhat controversial debate: the regulation of underground burrowing, specifically tunneling. The case involved a synagogue in New York City, where illegal digging beneath the structure led to a conflict that escalated into arrests and the filling of the tunnel.
Background and Context
A secret tunnel beneath a synagogue in New York City, reportedly a mikvah (ritual bath house), was discovered to have been dug illegally. This tunnel dispute stems from a schism within the Jewish community, with the NYPD becoming involved for both illegal digging and to maintain peace.
A group of twenty younger, Orthodox Jewish men attempted to occupy and protect the space, leading to a violent confrontation when law enforcement intervened. While the conflict was undoubtedly complex, it highlighted the issue of strict regulations on burrowing activities.
Regulations and Their Critique
The stringent regulations on digging tunnels and holes in the ground are indeed perplexing. Even non-extractive digging, such as my friend’s attempt to dig a pit on his rural property to build a greenhouse, was halted by a rural council.
Despite the risks they allegedly pose, there are countless documented cases of people safely digging tunnels for fun and other purposes on private property. These instances often involve meticulous planning and adherence to safe practices. However, such activities are frequently halted by bureaucratic measures, leading to unnecessary restrictions on an otherwise harmless activity.
Security Concerns and Ethical Considerations
One might argue that such activities could present security risks, prompting strict regulations. However, these concerns are often exaggerated. Many people who dig tunnels or burrow do so safely and without malicious intent, as evidenced by the case of my friend who intended to construct a greenhouse. The real question is whether the potential benefits outweigh the risks.
The urge to explore and dig underground is a fundamental human desire. As children, my friends and I would frequently explore sewer and subway tunnels, sometimes with more dangerous outcomes, but often for sheer enjoyment. Encouraging this natural curiosity on private property, like my friend’s wish to build an underground cubby house, could be more effective and less harmful.
The Role of Community and Flexibility
Communities play a critical role in managing such activities responsibly. However, current regulatory frameworks often lack the flexibility needed to balance safety, community interests, and individual rights. Loosening restrictions in a controlled manner could allow for safer and more productive use of space while still protecting public safety.
Finally, the world must reconsider why we are so averse to letting people engage in such enjoyable, albeit unconventional, activities. It’s understandable to regulate certain aspects of society for the greater good, but the current regulations often go too far, stifling creativity and spontaneous human behavior.
Thus, the question of whether burrowing should be considered a fundamental right is not merely about land-use laws but about recognizing and fostering human nature.