Would You Update an Old Brick Fireplace by Tiling Around It?

Updating a fireplace, especially one with tired, old brick, can be a challenging task. Many homeowners consider tiling around the brick to modernize the look of their living space. However, is this the best approach? In this article, we will explore alternative methods and recommendations to help you make an informed decision.

Traditional Methods of Updating an Old Brick Fireplace

Traditionally, the brick in an old fireplace is either left as is or cleaned and then either stone or tile work is added around it. However, tiling around the brick can be labor-intensive and messy, especially if there is carpeting nearby. Additionally, newer methods such as using cement board or real cement are often employed for a cleaner, more durable result.

New Approaches for Fireplaces

Instead of tiling, consider covering the brick with a fireproof material like cement board or real cement, followed by a tile application. This approach often requires less maintenance and can be more cost-effective. For example, one contractor, who has worked on many bank rehabs, has found that tiling around the brick does not significantly improve the aesthetics as much as some would believe.

Alternative Solutions

For those looking for a more personalized touch, consider a live edge mantle piece on columns or brackets, or opt for sandblasting the brick to give it a new, unique look. Another option is to add an insert to the existing wood-burning fireplace, as traditional wood-burning fireplaces are often net energy wasters. Installation of a modern, efficient fireplace insert can improve functionality without compromising aesthetics.

Painting and Maintaining the Brick Fireplace

When it comes to maintaining an old brick fireplace, painting the brick and dressing up the wood trim above can be a simple yet effective solution. If you are concerned about smoke issues, ensure that the damper is properly maintained and positioned. For those who want a more contemporary look, consider whitewashing the brick to give it a newer visual appeal.

Professional Cleaning and Maintenance

Before considering any major updates, it is recommended to have the brick fireplace professionally cleaned and tuck-pointed, if necessary. This ensures that the existing brick is in the best possible condition before applying any additional materials or treatments. Remember, brick is naturally durable and should not appear "tired" with proper maintenance.

Conclusion

While tiling around an old brick fireplace can be an attractive option, it is not without its drawbacks. Consider the above suggestions for alternative methods and personal touches to give your fireplace a modern, personalized look. Always ensure the fireplace is in good working condition and properly maintained for safety and efficiency.